Bing AI Mode vs Copilot: only 14% of cited websites overlap

Tarsh SwarnkarTanay10 min read
Venn diagram comparing Copilot and Bing AI Mode citations highlighting a 14% overlap and differing sources.

If you track AI visibility, your Microsoft numbers probably looked steady in November. Ours did too.

By November, Copilot required a login, and Bing AI Mode became Microsoft’s answer engine for everyone else. We ran the same 15,563 prompts from 134 brands through both engines, two weeks apart, and checked the dashboard. Brand visibility hadn’t budged. We assumed nothing had changed.

We were wrong.

On the dashboard, nothing moved. The same brands showed up at the same rate, in answers from the same company.

Inside the answers, almost everything did. The websites were different, the #1 brand changed on most prompts, and individual brands won or lost ground while the average stayed flat.

TL;DR

  • Different websites. Ask Copilot and Bing AI Mode the same question, and they share about 1 in 7 of the websites they cite.
  • Twice the sources. Bing AI Mode cites about 9 websites per answer. Copilot cites about 5.
  • Same score, new winners. Brands appear in 36% of answers on both engines, yet the top-ranked brand changed on 63% of prompts, and 1 in 5 brands moved 10 points or more.
  • Reviews up, retail down. Forbes, Gartner, and G2 show up 4x to 7x more often. Amazon's share of citations fell 6x.
  • Your website counts more. Bing AI Mode cites a brand's own site in 24% of answers, more than double Copilot's 11%.

Two Microsoft engines under one brand

Microsoft has renamed its AI search more often than most marketers can track.

  • The new AI-powered Bing put chat into search in February 2023, and that chat later became Copilot.
  • In April 2025, Microsoft launched Copilot Search in Bing, a full-page AI answer at bing.com/copilotsearch.
  • Microsoft now calls that page AI Mode and says both AI Mode and AI Overview run on Copilot.

One brand name covers two products that work differently:

CopilotBing AI Mode
Where it livescopilot.combing.com/copilotsearch
What it isAI assistantAI search results page
Web searchCopilot decides per promptRuns on every prompt
Answers behind a loginYes, since November 2026No

Shared branding makes it easy to assume both engines read the same web. We tested that assumption.

1. The same prompt pulls from different websites

The assumption failed. For the same prompt, Copilot and Bing AI Mode share 14% of the domains they cite. Comparing a single day on each engine, fewer than 1 in 100 prompts kept even half their sources.

AI answers drift on their own, so that gap only means something next to each engine's normal churn. Ask Bing AI Mode the same prompt a day later, and the cited domains overlap by 66%. For Copilot, the overlap is 45% a day later and still 39% ten days later.

Switching engines drops them to 14%. Over two days, a typical prompt cites about 7 domains on Copilot and 11 or 12 on Bing AI Mode, and 2 of them appear on both lists.

We found a similar split across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews in our 161,286-prompt citation overlap study. Here, both engines come from Microsoft, and they still cite different websites.

2. Bing AI Mode reads twice as many websites

A Bing AI Mode answer cites 9.4 different domains on average, against 4.6 for Copilot.

Copilot also cites the same domain more than once in an answer. About 17% of its citations repeat a site already cited, compared with 4% on Bing AI Mode. And Copilot leans on a short list: the 30 most-cited domains take 18% of its citations, twice their 9% share on Bing AI Mode.

The product design explains much of this. Bing AI Mode is a results page, so it runs a web search on every prompt and shows a full reference list. Copilot is an assistant that decides when to search.

3. The average held. Individual brands moved.

Twice the websites didn't mean more brands listed in the answer. Both engines name 6.5 tracked brands per answer, and own-brand visibility sits at 36.2% on Copilot and 36.4% on Bing AI Mode. When a brand is mentioned, it ranks first about 45% of the time on both.

Look one level down, and the flat line breaks apart.

  • The #1 brand changed on 63% of prompts. Within a single engine, that happens on 37% to 45%.
  • Gains and losses cancel out. Brands dropped out of 9.7% of their prompts and showed up on 9.6% where they hadn’t been.
  • 1 in 5 brands swung 10+ points. Of 95 brands with enough answers on both engines, 7 gained and 12 lost. Within one engine, only 3% to 6% of brands move that far.

Take a prompt like "Where's the best place to buy event tickets online?" Copilot ranks one resale marketplace first and cites 4 sites. Bing AI Mode ranks a different marketplace first and cites 10, including Forbes.

4. Review sites and publishers gained. Retail lost.

The sources shifted in a clear direction. Bing AI Mode leans on reviewers, analysts and publishers, and pulls back from retail listings. G2 appeared in 4.7% of Bing AI Mode answers, up from 1.2%. Forbes rose from 0.7% to 4.2%, and Gartner from 0.4% to 2.5%.

Only 4 domains make both top 10 lists: Amazon, worldmetrics.org, gitnux.org and G2. Copilot's list leans on retailers and statistics aggregators. Bing AI Mode swaps most of them for review sites and publishers.

#Copilot's top 10Copilot → Bing AI ModeBing AI Mode's top 10Copilot → Bing AI Mode
1amazon.com9.4% → 5.5%worldmetrics.org5.9% → 8.1%
2worldmetrics.org5.9% → 8.1%amazon.com9.4% → 5.5%
3walmart.com4.9% → 2.0%g2.com1.2% → 4.7%
4zipdo.co4.5% → 1.7%forbes.com0.7% → 4.2%
5wifitalents.com3.5% → 2.1%gitnux.org3.4% → 3.5%
6gitnux.org3.4% → 3.5%guideflow.com1.2% → 3.3%
7etsy.com1.7% → 0.1%sourceforge.net0.1% → 3.1%
8scienceinsights.org1.6% → 0%softwareadvice.com0.1% → 2.8%
9ruv.de1.4% → 2.2%hubspot.com1.2% → 2.6%
10g2.com1.2% → 4.7%gartner.com0.4% → 2.5%

Amazon was Copilot's most-cited source. Across all its storefronts, it held 6.0% of Copilot's citations and 0.9% of Bing AI Mode's.

Shopping units changed too. Copilot showed organic shopping cards in 14.6% of answers. The product units we capture on Bing AI Mode are sponsored ads, in 5.5% of answers. Retailers still get organic citations there, just a lot fewer.

Two smaller shifts round this out. Reddit, Wikipedia, and LinkedIn grew from a tiny base. Reddit went from 0.03% to 1.6% of answers, Wikipedia from 0.2% to 2.3%, and LinkedIn from 0.3% to 2.4%. And Bing AI Mode's single most-cited domain is worldmetrics.org, a statistics aggregator, in 8.1% of answers, while zipdo.co and wifitalents.com lost ground. Statistics aggregators rank this high partly because of the kinds of prompts we track, so their place in these lists reflects our data, not the web as a whole.

This lines up with what we saw in our 2,000-brand study of which sources influence AI answers: third-party coverage on trusted review and media sites moves visibility more than most brand-owned content.

Writesonic Turnover report cover

The #1 brand in ChatGPT changes 52% of the time.

Get the report and find out why.

5. Brand websites show up in twice as many answers

Brands' own sites gained alongside the reviewers. Bing AI Mode cites a brand's website in 24.3% of answers, against 11.0% on Copilot.

The total share of citations barely moved, 3.6% on Copilot and 3.4% on Bing AI Mode. The spread changed. Copilot cited a brand site in fewer answers but about twice per answer when it did. Bing AI Mode cites it in more answers, usually once, next to a longer list of third-party sources.

The gain holds across every type of prompt. On commercial prompts, brand-site citations rose from 8.2% to 21.0% of answers. On navigational prompts, from 16.5% to 30.6%.

In practice, a page on your site that answers a buyer's question directly now has a better shot at a citation. Our guide on how to get cited by AI covers what those pages need.

What to do now

If you report to leadership, start a fresh Bing AI Mode baseline. Comparing it line by line with Copilot history will show a flat trend and miss the brands that moved. Report the #1-brand rate and the sources behind it next to visibility.

You can do this week's work by hand:

  • Run your top 10 buying prompts on bing.com/copilotsearch and list the domains each answer cites.
  • Compare that list with the sites you targeted for Copilot. Expect most of them to be missing.
  • Update your G2, Capterra, Gartner, and Software Advice profiles. In the B2B software brands we track, review sites appeared in 30% of Bing AI Mode answers, up from 8%. That's 7 brands, so treat it as a direction rather than a rule.
  • Find the pages on your site that answer buying questions, and tighten them so a single section can stand as the answer.

Manual checks break after a few dozen prompts. They also can’t tell you which competitor took your #1 spot, or whether the sources shift again next month. That's where GEO tracking earns its keep.

Writesonic tracks Bing AI Mode as its own platform, so you can build a fresh baseline next to your Copilot history. Filter any dashboard to Bing AI Mode, and you see your share of voice, how often you're cited, and which pages mention you, with the competitors ranked above you in the leaderboard.

Bing AI Mode as its own platform in Writesonic, with share of voice, citations and a competitor leaderboard.

Book a demo to see your Bing AI Mode sources next to your Copilot history.

Questions we're still investigating

  • Does the 14% overlap hold over a month, or do the two engines drift closer together?
  • Why does worldmetrics.org rise while zipdo.co and wifitalents.com fall?
  • Do the review-site gains in B2B software hold across more than 7 brands?
  • Do sponsored product ads replace retailers' organic presence on Bing AI Mode, or sit beside it?

Track the engine, not the average

Microsoft has put its AI answers under four names in under four years: Bing Chat, Copilot, Copilot Search, and now AI Mode. With the latest switch, Copilot moved behind a login, and the answers your buyers read now draw on a different set of websites.

Microsoft might change it again. Track each engine on its own, and you'll spot the next switch within a week. Track one combined visibility number, and you may only find out when leads drop and nobody can say why.

Start a free trial of Writesonic to catch the next switch the week it happens, or book a demo for a walkthrough of your Bing AI Mode citations prompt by prompt.

How we did this

We used aggregated, anonymized tracking data from Writesonic projects: same brands, same prompts, two engines.

  • Copilot window: November 1 to 2, 2026, before the login change.
  • Bing AI Mode window: November 14 to 15, 2026.
  • Matched set: only prompts with a successful answer on both engines, which gave 15,563 prompts across 134 projects, with 31,113 Copilot answers and 30,963 Bing AI Mode answers.
  • Baselines: each engine compared with itself in one-day windows. Copilot on October 23, November 1 and November 2. Bing AI Mode on November 14, 15 and 16.
  • Overlap: the Jaccard index of cited domains (or tracked brands) per prompt, meaning domains cited by both engines divided by all domains cited by either.
  • Brands and first-party citations: brand mentions come from each project's tracked brand and competitor list. A first-party citation is one on the brand's own domain, subdomains included. The #1 brand is the best-ranked tracked brand in an answer.

From November 5, more and more of our Copilot requests hit a login wall, so the Copilot window ends on November 2.

Limitations. The two windows sit two weeks apart, but a 10-day Copilot baseline shows time alone explains little of the gap. Two days per engine is a short read, so we'll rerun this as Bing AI Mode data grows. Not every project tracked both engines, so we only compared prompts answered on both. Bing AI Mode answers outside that set look about the same, at 33% visibility and 6.1 brands per answer. For shopping units, our tracking captures organic cards on Copilot and sponsored ads on Bing AI Mode.

Frequently asked questions

What is Bing AI Mode?

Bing AI Mode is Microsoft's AI search results page at bing.com/copilotsearch. It launched in April 2025 as Copilot Search, runs a web search on every prompt, and lists the sources behind each answer. Microsoft says it runs on Copilot technology.

Is Bing AI Mode the same as Copilot?

No. Both run on Copilot technology, but Copilot is an AI assistant at copilot.com that decides when to search, while Bing AI Mode is a search page that searches on every prompt. In our study, the two engines shared about 14% of the websites they cited for the same prompt.

Microsoft says Copilot Search on Bing became two features: AI Overview, a short summary at the top of Bing results, and AI Mode, a full-page AI answer that takes follow-up questions. AI Mode still lives at bing.com/copilotsearch.

Does my Copilot visibility carry over to Bing AI Mode?

On average, yes: brands appeared in 36.2% of Copilot answers and 36.4% of Bing AI Mode answers. Brand by brand, it often doesn't. The top-ranked brand changed on 63% of prompts, and 1 in 5 brands moved 10 or more points, so check your own numbers rather than the average.

How do I get my brand cited in Bing AI Mode?

In our data, Bing AI Mode leaned on review sites, publishers and brands' own websites. Keep your G2, Capterra, Gartner and Software Advice profiles current, and publish pages that answer buying questions directly, so a single section can stand as the answer.

Writesonic Turnover report cover

The #1 brand in ChatGPT changes 52% of the time.

Get the report and find out why.

Tarsh Swarnkar
Tarsh Swarnkar

Data & Infrastructure @ Writesonic

Tarsh builds the data pipelines behind Writesonic's AI visibility research, including the AI Ads Index. His work focuses on real-time measurement of how AI platforms cite, mention, and rank brands.

Tanay
Tanay

Growth Marketer

Tanay covers the intersection of AI and marketing at Writesonic.
His work focuses on how LLMs and AI Agents are reshaping search, and how marketing teams can adapt their SEO and content strategies for an AI-first search landscape.

Get our best insights, weekly

Join 5000+ marketers getting data-backed strategies on AI search visibility and SEO. No fluff.

  • No spam.
  • Unsubscribe anytime

Keep reading